Financial Planning Case #1: The Johnsons Decide to Buy a Car. After
three years of riding a bus to work, Belinda finds that she can no
longer do so because her employer moved to a location that is not
convenient for public transportation. Thus the Johnsons are in the
market for another car. Harry and Belinda estimate that they could
afford to spend about $10,000 on a good used car by making a down
payment of $2,000 and financing the remainder over 24 months at $355 per
- a) Make
suggestions about how the $355 might be integrated into the Johnsons’
budget (Table 3-5 on page 86) by making reductions in certain expense
- b) If they
cannot make room in their budget for a $355 monthly car payment, would
you recommend they finance a vehicle for 36 or 48 months? Why or why
- c) Which sources of used cars should they consider? Why?
- d) Assume that
the Johnsons have narrowed their choices to two cars. The first car is a
three-year-old Chevrolet Malibu with 4,000 miles; it is being sold for
$10,000 by a private individual. The seller has kept records of all
maintenance and repairs. The second car is a three-year-old Ford Fusion
with 28,000 miles, being sold by a used-car dealership. Harry contacted
the previous owner and found that the car was given in trade on another
car about three months ago. The previous owner cited no major mechanical
problems but simply wanted a bigger car. The dealer is offering a
written 30-day warranty on parts only. The asking price is $10,400.
Which used car would you advise the Johnsons to buy? Why?
- e) Would you recommend that they purchase or lease a low-priced new vehicle instead of buying a used vehicle? Why or why not?
Financial Planning Case #4: Michael and Jonathan Weigh the Benefits and Costs of Buying Versus Renting. Michael
Higginbottom and Jonathan Van Ness of Logan, Utah, are trying to decide
whether to rent or purchase housing. Both men are single. Michael
favors buying and Jonathan leans toward renting, and both seem able to
justify their particular choice. Michael thinks that the tax advantages
are a very good reason for buying. Jonathan, however, believes that cash
flow is so much better when renting. See whether you can help them make
- a) Does the home buyer enjoy tax advantages? Explain.
- b) Discuss Jonathan’s belief that cash flow is better with renting.
- c) Suggest some reasons why Michael might consider renting rather than purchasing housing.